The German energy industry is evaluating the implications of the new US administration's fossil fuel policy on their country's energy strategy, particularly in the context of blue hydrogen production. While some industry leaders view the policy announcements positively and advocate for incorporating blue hydrogen—a form of hydrogen produced using fossil fuels—into Germany's energy transition plans, others, like the Green Party, remain skeptical. The debate centers around the challenges of achieving the planned green hydrogen production targets by 2030 and the potential role of blue hydrogen in meeting industrial gas demands. Despite reservations from some political quarters, proponents argue that embracing blue hydrogen could enhance Germany's industrial competitiveness and address the current limitations in scaling up green hydrogen production. The discussion also touches on the economic implications of relying on US natural gas for hydrogen production, with varying opinions on the country's energy independence and environmental sustainability. As Germany navigates these discussions, the article highlights the evolving energy landscape and the need for a balanced approach to hydrogen production to meet both economic and climate goals.